Program Information

The Water Equivalence of Organic Liquid Scintillators for Proton Dosimetry

W S Ingram*, D Robertson, S Beddar, UT M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX

SU-E-T-116 Sunday 3:00:00 PM - 6:00:00 PM Room: Exhibit Hall

Purpose: Torganic liquid scintillators are currently under investigation for use in proton dosimetry. The purpose of this work is to evaluate the water equivalence of these materials as a preliminary step to identify scintillators that are well-suited to this purpose.

Methods: Stopping powers were calculated for 0.001-1000 MeV protons in water, polystyrene, and two organic liquid scintillators: BC-531 and OptiPhase 'Hi-Safe' 3 at 0%, 25%, and 50% concentrations of water. Angular scatter was quantified by theta0, a characteristic multiple Coulomb scattering angle analogous to the standard deviation of a Gaussian distribution of proton angles relative to the incident beam axis. Theta0 was calculated as a function of depth over the range of 200 MeV protons in these materials.

Results: Collisional stopping power in BC-531 ranged from +44% to +1% of that in water. It remained within 6% from 2-600 MeV. OptiPhase ranged from +24% to -2%, with smaller deviations at increased water concentrations. At all concentrations, OptiPhase showed smaller deviations than polystyrene and BC-531 and remained within 1% of water from 2-600 MeV.

Theta0 was very similar for all materials, with deviations from water of 5 milliradians or less over the majority of the proton range. BC-531 showed deviations of 10 milliradians or more in the last few millimeters of the range. OptiPhase showed smaller deviations than BC-531 or polystyrene, and these deviations decreased with increasing water concentration.

Conclusions: OptiPhase was found to be more water equivalent than BC-531 or polystyrene in stopping power and angular scatter, and increased water concentration improved both quantities. Large deviations in stopping power were only found below 2 MeV for any material, where proton range is less than 0.1 millimeter. The deviations from water found in angular scatter were less significant, and probably too small to affect measurement.

Contact Email